Sequoia Litigation Update

Sequoia Resources Litigation Information

Second Application to the Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta to strike BIA claim and summary dismissal

February 25, 2020 Application to strike BIA Claim and summary dismissal
Affidavit of Mark Schweitzer
Perpetual memorandum of argument
Trustee's memorandum of argument 

Intervenor Applications

Decision Order July 31, 2020

Orphan Well Association Application
Orphan Well Association Application Brief
Orphan Well Association Affidavit
Orphan Well Association Reply Brief

E&P Co's Application
E&P Co's Application Brief
CNRL Affidavit
Cenovus Affidavit
Torxen Affidavit
E&P Co's Reply

Perpetual Brief
Sue Riddell Rose Brief

Application for Costs to the Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta regarding February 18, 2020 Order

Perpetual Application for Costs
Susan Riddell Rose Application for Costs
Affidavit of Susan Riddell Rose  
Susan Riddell Rose memorandum of argument
Perpetual memorandum of argument
Trustee's memorandum of argument 

Application for security for costs to the Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta
Application for Security for Costs
Affidavit of Mark Schweitzer
Perpetual memorandum of argument 
Trustee's memorandum of argument

Application of Paul Darby, in his personal capacity, to intervene in the Trustee's application to a Panel of the Court of Appeal (filed Feb 26, 2020)

Decision Order June 18, 2020
Decision Order June 18, 2020 - Memorandum of Judgement
Darby Application to Intervene
Darby Memorandum of Argument
Affidavit of Paul Darby
Perpetual Memorandum of Argument in response to Darby application (filed June 8, 2020)
Susan Riddell Rose Memorandum of Argument in response to Darby application (filed June 5, 2020)
Transcript of Oral Questioning - Paul Darby held May 26, 2020

Trustee's application to refer it's February 10, 2020 application to a Panel of the Court of Appeal (filed Feb 13, 2020)

Decision Order June 18, 2020
Decision Order June 18, 2020 - Memorandum of Judgement
Application of the Trustee
Memorandum of argument of the Trustee
Affidavit of Paul Darby
Memorandum of argument of Susan Riddell Rose responding to the Trustee's application (filed Feb 19, 2020)
Memorandum of argument of Perpetual responding to the Trustee's application (filed Feb 19, 2020)
Letter from Court of Appeal dated Feb 18, 2020 directing referral of Trustee's application to a Panel

Application of the Trustee to set aside or modify reasons for the January 29,2020 decision (filed Feb 10, 2020)
Application of the Trustee
Trustee's memorandum of argument
Memorandum of argument of Susan Riddell Rose responding to the Trustee's application
Memorandum of argument of Perpetual responding to the Trustee's application

Application for Costs to the Court of Appeal of Alberta
Norton Rose Fulbright letter to Laurie Baptiste dated May 1, 2020
Burnet, Duckworth & Palmer letter to Laurie Baptiste dated May 1, 2020
Affidavit of Susan Riddell RoseTrustee's Appeal of January 29, 2020 Appeal Court decision requiring the Trustee to post security for costs:

Perpetual and Susan Riddell Rose Court of Appeal Security for Costs Application

January 29, 2020

Court of Appeal of Alberta Security for Costs Application: Reasons for Decision

November 15, 2019

Court of Appeal of Alberta Security for Costs Application: Trustee's Memorandum of Argument

November 14, 2019

Court of Appeal of Alberta Security for Costs Application: Transcript of Questioning of Paul Darby

October 21, 2019

Court of Appeal of Alberta Security for Costs Application:  Affidavit of Paul Darby

September 24, 2019
Court of Appeal of Alberta Application for an Order Directing the Trustee to Post Security for Appeal Costs:

Application of Susan Riddell Rose

Memorandum of Argument of Susan Riddell Rose

Affidavit of Susan Riddell Rose

Application of Perpetual Energy Inc.

Memorandum of Argument of Perpetual Energy Inc.

Appeal of Trustee Statement of Claim - Court of Queen's Bench Summary Dismissal Application Decision filed February 18, 2020
Perpetual's Factum filed May 29, 2020
Trustee's Factum filed May 29, 2020
Joint application of defendants to appeal August 15th judgement
Trustee's application to appeal August 15th judgement

 

Trustee Statement of Claim

February 18, 2020
Court Order of the Honourable Justice D. B. Nixon

January 13, 2020
Reasons for Judgment of the Honourable Mr. Justice D.B. Nixon

August 15, 2019

Court transcript - oral reasons for judgement

June 14, 2019
Joint Reply of Defendants to the Trustee's June 11, 2019 Submissions - June 14, 2019

June 11, 2019
Trustee's Additional Submissions June 11, 2019

June 4, 2019
Joint Submission of Defendants June 4, 2019

December 17, 2018
Court Transcripts December 17, 2018 Hearing

November 9, 2018
Court Transcripts November 9, 2018 Hearing

November 8, 2018
Court Transcripts November 8, 2018 Hearing

November 1, 2018
Transcript of Oral Questioning - Mark Schweitzer filed November 1, 2018

Transcript of Oral Questioning - Susan Riddell Rose filed November 1, 2018

Transcript of Oral Questioning - Paul J. Darby filed November 1, 2018

Brief of the Defendant Susan Riddell Rose filed November 1, 2018

Brief of the Defendants Perpetual Energy Inc., Perpetual Operating Trust, Perpetual Operating Corp. filed November 1, 2018
Brief of the Plaintiff PwC filed November 1, 2018

October 19, 2018
Rose Amended, Amended Application for Summary Dismissal and Striking of Pleadings filed October 19, 2018

Affidavit of Susan Riddell Rose filed October 19, 2018

October 4, 2018
Affidavit of Mark Schweitzer filed October 4, 2018

September 21, 2018
Rose Amended Application for Summary Dismissal filed September 21, 2018

August 27, 2018
Perpetual Statement of Defence filed August 27, 2018

Perpetual Application for Summary Dismissal filed August 27, 2018

Perpetual Application to Resolve filed August 27, 2018

Rose Statement of Defence filed August  27, 2018

Rose Application for Summary Dismissal filed August 27, 2018

Rose Application to Resolve filed August 27, 2018

August 2, 2018
Statement of Claim ~ Action No. 1801-10960 filed August 2, 2018

Application ~ Action No. 1801-10960 filed August 2, 2018

Affidavit of Paul J. Darby ~ Action 1801-10960 filed and sworn August 2, 2018